Advanced Search
 
The alternative vote +
All about the Alternative Vote Plus, how it works and the pros and cons
Alternative Vote Plus
Where is AV+ used?

AV+ has yet to be put into practice anywhere in the world.

How does the Alternative Vote Plus work?


The Alternative Vote Plus (AV+) uses the Alternative Vote (in which voters rank candidates in order of preference) to elect a candidate in each constituency, and then uses a small top-up list to make the overall result more proportional.

Voters can either select their favourite party or choose their favourite candidate from the top-up list and the votes are then allocated to represent each party’s share of the votes proportionally

Pros and cons of the Alternative Vote Plus

The case for AV+ The arguments against

Elected MPs would have the support of a majority of their local electorates.

All existing constituency boundaries would have to be redrawn.

Being able to rank candidates increases voter choice, as does having both a constituency vote and a regional vote.

Ballot papers would be more complicated than First Past The Post ones.

Nearly every elector would have at least one vote that would have an effect on the overall election result.

It creates two classes of representative, which could create animosity between them and a confusion of roles.

Parties would have an incentive to campaign across the whole country, and not just in the marginals.

The final result will be fairer, with parties having a share of MPs based on their support among the electorate, rather than on electoral arithmetic and geographical oddities.

AV+ will produce majority governments when the voters express a desire for one, but will force them to work together when the electorate choose not to give any one party a clear majority.

Tactical voting would no longer be necessary.

hello

Other voting systems by type

Proportional Representation
Party List PR
Single Transferable Vote

Mixed Systems 
Additional Member System
Alternative Vote Plus

Majoritarian Systems
Alternative Vote
Block Vote
Borda Count
First Past The Post
Limited Vote
Supplementary Vote
Two-Round System
Recent News
22nd September 2014
The ERS held its first Labour Party conference event this morning. The subject was “What next after the Scottish independence referendum?”   At one level this should not be so contentious – Scotland has been promised significant devolution of new powers by all three of the big Westminster parties. A very rapid timetable has been established […]
18th September 2014
Scotland is shrouded in a muggy haar today, and it feels as if we’ve been cut off from the rest of the world in order to concentrate and exercise our democratic right to vote: for or against independence. It feels like a reason to talk to strangers, smile at passers-by. We’re making history.   There’s […]
8th September 2014
Scotland is alive with an unprecedented level of political debate. In homes, pubs and town halls, that debate is not limited to technicalities; it’s about the way people want to be governed, the society they want to live in.   Go south of the border and you could already be in an entirely separate country. […]