England let down by elections as Scotland leads the way

Electoral Reform Society
Author:
Electoral Reform Society

Posted on the 9th May 2012

Since Thursday’s local elections we’ve been crunching the numbers. Did voters get a fair deal? What has breaking from First Past the Post meant for Scotland?

Well what we’re seeing is a widening gulf between local democracy in England and Scotland.

We’ve focused on six English and Scottish cities and its’ clear English voters are drawing the short straw – with less choice and less chance of affecting the result on polling day.

A tale of 6 Cities – Edinburgh, Glasgow, Dundee, Portsmouth, Birmingham, Manchester:

City Edin. Glas. Dundee Portsm. B.ham Manc.
Voter Choice

 

 

 

 

 

 

Candidates/Ward

7.47

10.67

7.75

3.86

5.23

4.91

Parties/Ward

6.41

8.38

5.63

3.79

5.20

4.75

Representation

 

 

 

 

 

 

Voters getting who they voted for (%)

72.66

75.93

79.78

46.17

54.98

65.22

Women’s representation (%)

25.86

30.38

24.14

14.30

42.50

34.4

Voting system

STV

STV

STV

FPTP

FPTP

FPTP

Estimated National Turnout

Scotland 42%

England 32%

Scotland abandoned First Past the Post for local government elections in 2007 and adopted the Single Transferrable Vote form of Proportional Representation. This has brought competitive elections into all the local ‘One Party States’ that once blighted Scottish politics.

Scottish voters got more choice at the polls and more chance of deciding who speaks in their name in their town halls. And while most Scots got a councillor they backed for their trouble, most of the English just threw their votes away (33,000 in Birmingham, 27,000 in Portsmouth, and 90,000 in Birmingham alone).

Glasgow has transformed itself from rotten borough to a multi-party democracy. Scotland now has a local democracy we can all be proud of, and getting rid of First Past the Post made that possible. With the Single Transferable Vote people have got a real say on who runs their local authorities.

Voters in England should settle for nothing less.

Read more posts...

Is there proportional representation in Scotland?

For most of the 20th century, every election in Scotland was conducted under the First Past the Post system, from elections of MPs to local councillors. Much like in the rest of the UK, this...

Posted 05 Sep 2019

Compared to Westminster, the Scottish Parliament is very proportional