National Democracy Week: Government ‘turning a blind eye’ to need for Westminster reform

Posted on the 29th June 2018

90th anniversary of the 1928 Equal Franchise Act comes amid ‘glaring political inequality’ in the UK, say campaigners

  • For immediate release, 29th June 2018
  • Darren Hughes and other spokespeople are available for interview and further comment.
  • The ERS will be releasing stories throughout Democracy Week – contact the press office for more information

The Electoral Reform Society say the government are ‘turning a blind eye’ to the need for reforms at Westminster, ahead of the first National Democracy Week [1].

The Cabinet Office scheme – which launches on Monday – is built on the premise that “regardless of who we are or where we are from, we must work together to ensure that every member of society has an equal chance to participate in our democracy and to have their say.” But it comes amid a growing democratic divide in the UK [2].

Monday is also the 90th anniversary of the 1928 Equal Franchise Act, which gave women the same voting rights as men.

However, the ERS are highlighting:

  • An unequal franchise in the UK – with 16 and 17-year olds denied a vote outside of Scotland
  • An ‘out of date and unjust’ voting system for Westminster and English local elections
  • A ‘political gender gap’ for women’s representation, with the government refusing to implement crucial legislation on candidate diversity data
  • A ‘bloated and undemocratic’ House of Lords, with the results for a hereditary peer by-election coming right in the middle of Democracy Week

The lack of reform is exacerbating glaring political inequalities – with National Democracy Week ‘at risk of glossing over the need for change’, according to campaigners.

In a comment piece for the ERS website, Darren Hughes writes that “this Democracy Week, the government must recognise Westminster’s politics is broken.”

The full article is available here.

Despite the government claiming to back ensuring ‘every member of society has an equal chance to participate in our democracy and to have their say’, we are nowhere near the that vision in the UK.

A broken voting system

Westminster’s broken voting system means that all votes cast for anyone but the winning candidates are discarded. But there’s another injustice not often discussed: all votes for the winning candidate above what they need to win are discarded too – they do not count towards the final result.

Over 22 million votes were wasted in these ways at the 2017 General Election. That’s a staggering 68% of the total.

There are fairer ways of electing representatives already in use in the UK. Voters in Scotland and Northern Ireland are used to ranking candidates – if their first choice vote isn’t needed, their second choice is taken instead, and so on. Votes aren’t thrown on the electoral scrapheap – and you don’t have to second-guess your fellow citizens by settling for a ‘lesser evil’.  

An unequal franchise

But on the 90th anniversary of the 1928 Equal Franchise Act – which gave women the same voting rights as men – we have to recognise that the UK’s franchise is grossly unequal.

In Scotland – and soon Wales – 16 and 17-year-olds have the vote for their elections. But they, and over a million in the rest of the UK, are denied a say for Westminster.

16 and 17-year-olds took part in huge numbers in the Scottish independence referendum. And they’ve stayed engaged since.

And in Wales, plans are afoot to extend a democratic say to those young adults.  

But these people will still be unable to vote in arguably the most important ballots, General Elections.

The experience from Scotland has revealed that 16 and 17-year-olds embrace the responsibility of being able to vote when they have it. So it’s time to fix Britain’s unequal franchise and extend that right.

A ‘House of Cronies’

The most startling inequality sits within the walls of Parliament though. Unlike the elected House of Commons, the Lords is largely made up of appointed life peers.

A vast number of these have previously worked in politics – and it has become something of a private member’s club.

There are even 92 hereditary peers – 91 men and one woman who inherited their titles. On Wednesday, the results will be announced for a ‘hereditary peer by-election’ – where aristocrats already in the Lords decide which aristocrats can vote on our laws for life. This, in the 21st century.

There is only one woman on the aristocrats’ approved candidates list.

The ‘political gender gap’

That’s not to say women are fairly represented in politics as a whole. With women making up only 33% of local councillors, only four out of 16 elected mayors, and no directly-elected metro-mayors, the issue of women’s representation extends well beyond the walls of Westminster.

But currently there is no official information on the diversity of those standing for election at any level of government.

Equality legislation already exists which would make this information transparent. Section 106 of the Equality Act (2010) requires political parties to publish diversity data on candidates standing in elections to the House of Commons and devolved administrations.

The problem is that the government has yet to enact it. Why are they dragging their feet on this simple change?

There is so much to be done to ensure everyone has equal access to politics in the UK. Thankfully, many of the changes won’t take much to implement.

But in this week of all weeks, it’s vital that we start trying to make that vision – for “an equal chance to participate in our democracy” – a reality.


Notes to Editors


[2] The latest Hansard Audit of Political Engagement found a drop in those ‘satisfied with the system of governing’ – yet a rise in political interest

Read more press releases...

Campaigners call for parties to back ‘vital’ Senedd reforms

Electoral Reform Society Cymru throws weight behind official Committee on Senedd Reform findings: “Now is the time to act to level up Welsh democracy”. Statement from the Electoral Reform Society Cymru – Thursday 10th September...

Posted 10 Sep 2020