Position on June 2018 Hereditary Peer By-elections

Posted on the 4th June 2018

A by-election has been called following the retirement of the 4th Earl Baldwin of Bewdley, grandson of Stanley Baldwin.

As a Crossbench Peer, his replacement will be selected by hereditary peers of the Crossbench group – 31 in total.

Eligible candidates are drawn from the Register of Hereditary Peers held by the Clerk of Parliaments. This list contains any hereditary peer who has expressed an interest in standing in a by-election.

Peers can join or leave the list at any time and the list is published annually: see here.

Out of 211 on the list, there is only one woman. 

During the last Crossbencher by-election in 2017 there were 10 candidates (and 31 eligible voters).

On the basis of previous turnout for crossbench by-elections, around 26 Peers will shortly decide which aristocrat remains in Parliament to vote on our laws, for the rest of their lives.

Background

The 1999 House of Lords Act removed all but 90 of the hereditary peers (plus holders of the offices of Earl Marshall and Lord Great Chamberlain) – 92 in total. 667 hereditary peers lost their right to sit in the Lords in these reforms.

Subsequently, vacancies that result from death (or retirement, resignation or exclusion since the House of Lords Reform Act 2014 and House of Lords (Expulsion and Suspension) Act 2015) are filled by by-election.

By-elections take place within party groups (except for 15 hereditary peers, originally elected to serve as office holders, whose successors are elected by the whole house). These party groups reflected the proportion of party affiliation at the time of the 1999 reforms. There are 49 Conservative hereditary peers, 4 Labour, 4 Liberal Democrat and 31 Crossbench hereditary peers (1 UKIP, 1 non-affiliated). See full breakdown here.

Where are the women?

There is only one female hereditary peer currently sitting in the House of Lords (The Countess of Mar).

Three of the original five female hereditary peers that remained following the 1999 reforms have since died and one retired in 2014. All four were replaced by male peers and there is only one female hereditary peer listed on the register of future candidates (June 2017). No female hereditary peer has been admitted to the House of Lords by by-election.

Hereditary by-elections – the figures

Elections to the House of Lords use the Alternative Vote. The first hereditary by-election was held in 2003 following the death of Viscount Oxford. According to ERS analysis:

  • Hereditary by-elections have an average of just 29 voters*. This compares to an average of 29,116 votes cast over the last 32 Commons by-elections – a larger democratic mandate by a factor of 1,000.
  • The average electorate for normal hereditary by-elections is just 32 (188 including whole-house elections).
  • 3,190 votes have been cast in total for the 32 peers elected in hereditary peer by-elections since 2003. By contrast, 931,725 votes have been cast in the last 32 House of Commons by-elections.
  • At its highest, the electorate has been 803, at its lowest just three.
  • Four by-elections have had more candidates than electors, including the only by-election within the Labour group of hereditary peers – for which there were 11 candidates and only 3 voters (30th October 2003).
  • The average turnout for by-elections is 83%. Three by-elections have had 100% turnout (all of which have had an electorate of four or fewer).

*This is for ‘normal’ by-elections – ones which do not involve the whole house. The figure is 100 when including the whole-house elections, which are for filling 15 official hereditary roles in the Lords, such as Deputy Speaker.

By-elections since 2013

Previous Peer Reason Electorate Date of Results No. of Candidates Electorate Turnout Turnout % Winning Candidate
Earl Ferrers Died Conservative 06/02/2013 27 48 46 96 Viscount Ridley
Lord Reay Died Whole House 17/07/2013 23 753 334 45 Lord Borwick
Lord Moran Died Crossbench 09/02/2014 13 29 27 93 Lord Cromwell
Lord Methuen Died Whole House 22/10/2014 15 776 283 36 Earl of Oxford and Asquith
Viscount Allenby of Megiddo Died Crossbench 10/12/2014 18 27 25 93 Lord Russell of Liverpool
Lord Cobbold Retired Crossbench 10/12/2014 18 27 25 93 Duke of Somerset
Lord Chorley Retired Crossbench 03/02/2015 18 28 26 93 Lord Thurlow
Lord Saftoun of Abernethy Retired Crossbench 03/02/2015 18 28 26 93 Earl of Kinnoul
Viscount Tenby Retired Crossbench 07/07/2015 19 28 25 89 Lord Mountevans
Lord Luke Retired Conservative 16/09/2015 16 48 41 85 Duke of Wellington
Viscount Mountgomery of Alamein Retired Crossbench 20/10/2015 17 29 26 90 Lord Trevethein and Oaksey
Lord Montagu of Beaulieu Died Conservative 24/11/2015 14 48 44 92 Lord Fairfax of Cameron
Lord Avebury Died Lib Dem 19/04/2016 7 3 3 100 Viscount Thurso
Lord Bridges Non-Attendance Crossbench 12/07/2016 17 31 27 87 Earl of Cork and Orrery
Lord Lyell Died Whole House 21/03/2017 27 803 346 43 Lord Colgrain
Lord Walpole Retired Crossbench 20/07/2017 10 31 27 87 Lord Vaux of Harrowden

Read more posts...

Briefing on the Democracy in the Dark Report

Download as PDF (130.5KB pdf) Democracy is about empowering citizens so they can actively take part in our political processes and make an informed decision at the ballot box. Transparency, fairness and accountability in political...

Posted 24 Sep 2020

Democracy in the Dark Preview