ERS: Polls show Westminster’s voting system now an ‘engine of instability’

Posted on the 4th July 2019

  • Statement from the Electoral Reform Society for immediate release, 4th July 2019.
  • Contact / 07717211630 for bids or more information

Campaigners have called for urgent reform of Westminster’s ‘undemocratic and discredited’ voting system, following a series of polls that reflect voters ‘shopping around more than ever’.

The latest YouGov poll for the Times has four parties hovering around 20% of the vote – suggesting the next election could see an unprecedentedly close race. Just a few percentage points up or down can be the difference between a party becoming the largest party in parliament or getting only a handful of MPs.

The UK is the only country in Europe that uses a First Past the Post system for its general elections. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland all use forms of proportional representation for devolved elections.

It forms part of a picture of record-breaking polls, with a YouGov poll last week showing the lowest ever vote share for a party in 1st place (22% for the Brexit Party and the Conservatives), and the second such poll with five parties on 10% or more [2].

A cross-party coalition of parties – including the Brexit Party and the Liberal Democrats – has called for electoral reform this week [3].

ERS spokesperson and Director of ERS Cymru Jess Blair said:

“This poll is part of a trend of party fragmentation that raises urgent questions about Westminster’s archaic electoral system.

“With four parties on around 20% of the vote, the one-person-takes-all system means each party is just a few percentage points between annihilation at the next election, or winning an unfair landslide.

“This absurd instability means it is now clearly in the national interest to back a democratic, proportional voting system that guarantees voters fair results and cooperation – not this bizarre lottery we have now.

“Millions are likely to feel forced to vote ‘tactically’ rather than for their first choice, and ‘vote-splitting’ may lead to unprecedented volatility and random results. First Past the Post – far from being ‘strong and stable’ – is now an engine of uncertainty.

“We are now a multi-party democracy operating under a broken, one-person-takes-all voting system. It is time for an electoral system that delivers voters the representation they deserve.”


Notes of Editors




Read more posts...